There are practical considerations that limit BOG value. Using the exchange as a benchmark — even if you ultimately bet with a bookmaker — is one of the most effective habits a punter can develop. If the exchange offers 7.0 and the bookmaker offers 5/1, the bookmaker is taking a significantly larger margin on that runner, and you should either back on the exchange or find a bookmaker whose price is closer to the exchange level.
The commission you pay on an exchange winning bet reduces your effective odds. There is a subtlety that experienced exchange users understand and newcomers often miss. The back horse racing sites not on gamstop price might be 6.0 but only fifty pounds is available at that price, and the lay price might be 7.0 — a gap that represents poor value for anyone trying to trade. That difference — roughly 10 per cent on the individual price — is the cost of the bookmaker margin. The exchange takes a commission on the net winnings of the winning side, typically between 2 and 5 per cent depending on the user’s activity level. Instead of setting odds and accepting bets against them, the exchange matches punters on opposite sides of a bet.
Bookmakers open with a cautious book and adjust as money comes in. The first show of prices in the morning — often called the early prices — tends to carry a wider margin than the Starting Price. On the raceday market itself, there are consistent patterns. Ante-post markets on the Cheltenham Gold Cup or Champion Hurdle typically run between 140 and 160 per cent, which is lower than the National but still significantly wider than raceday. The aggregate effect across 20 runners adds up to a much wider margin than in a six-runner race. At the lower end, you find small-field Flat races — Group 1 contests with five or six runners where the form is well established and bookmakers compete aggressively on the headline price of the favourite.
The difference between 5/1 and 6/1 on the same horse in the same race is a 20 per cent increase in profit — free money, essentially, for the 30 seconds it takes to check a second bookmaker. Each-way is unprofitable on short-priced horses where place returns are minimal, in small fields with weak terms, and when your assessment favours win-or-nothing outcomes. BOG value emerges when horses attract late support and steam into shorter prices, while your early-morning selection drifts in consequence. Always check the specific terms at your chosen bookmaker before calculating whether each-way represents value. For punters betting on the morning’s early races or taking ante-post positions that settle on the day, checking the activation window is essential.
On horses that are supported in the market — money coming in, price shortening — BOG adds nothing, because the SP is lower than the price you took. Check the exchange price on your selection before placing with a bookmaker. Flutter Entertainment, which owns Betfair, reported global revenue of $14 billion in 2024 across 13.9 million average monthly users, but the exchange is only one part of that portfolio, and liquidity varies enormously by market.
A horse drifting from 5/1 to 7/1 represents an opportunity for those who took the early price under Best Odds Guaranteed. But the punter who simply opens an account with one bookmaker and accepts whatever price they see is leaving money on the table. Bookmakers are fighting for your custom with promotions like Best Odds Guaranteed, enhanced place terms, and competitive pricing. Horse racing punters, in other words, are moving serious money through these markets, and the opportunities for finding value in UK racing have never been more varied. Over a season of betting, that difference compounds into hundreds or thousands of pounds left on the table—or captured, depending on your approach. The difference between taking 5/1 at one bookmaker and 11/2 at another might look trivial on paper.
If the exchange back price is 8.0 and the best bookmaker is offering 6/1, the bookmaker is taking a significantly wider margin on that horse. Open Betfair or Smarkets and look at the back price on your selection. For any given horse, you can see the best available price highlighted, and the difference between the best and worst price is often two or three points of odds — the difference between 7/1 and 5/1 on the same horse in the same race.
If the exchange offers 6.0 and the bookmaker offers 5/1, the bookmaker is competitive after commission. The practical approach for most punters is to use both. When should you use the exchange, and when should you use a bookmaker?